If you have been pricing floating docks and landed on Tommy Docks, you have probably noticed that four packages to cover 128 square feet adds up to $5,100 before anchoring or freight. The main alternative is to build a framed dock yourself using a hardware kit, dock floats and lumber you source locally. The floating dock kits at Dock Builders Supply are the perfect answer to Tommy Docks and are sold as complete kits that include the framing hardware and the floats. Lumber and decking are extra, bought locally because freight on lumber is prohibitive. That honest difference is what makes the per-square-foot numbers believable, and the numbers favor the DIY route heavily. This article shows what each option actually costs, which site and situation each one fits, and what you give up either way.
Key Takeaways
- An 8x16 framed dock kit from DockBuilders.com costs $1,427.46 in hardware and flotation, against $5,100 for four Tommy Docks packages covering the same area.
- That is roughly $11.15 per square foot versus $39.84, before you add lumber and decking on the DIY side or anchoring on either side.
- Kits include the floats, framing hardware, lags and fasteners. You supply frame lumber, decking and connection hardware like hoops or pipe holders.
- Modular packages suit small platforms, seasonal removal and anyone who will not pick up a saw. Framed builds suit anything over about 128 square feet, non-rectangular shapes and permanent installs.
- Neither route includes the hardware that secures the dock to the bottom or a structure. Budget for anchoring regardless of which way you go.
- A damaged float on a framed dock is unbolted and replaced from stock. A damaged proprietary module depends on one supplier still carrying the part.
What You Get in a Pre-Packaged Dock
Tommy Docks sells their floating dock line as modular panels. Each 8' Floating Dock Package (SKU TDFXS-48) is priced at $1,275.00 and covers 32 square feet finished. Inside the box you get two FLEXX polyethylene floats, each 4 ft x 4 ft x 15 in and rated at 650 lb of support, for a combined 1,300 lb per package. Two FLEXX connector kits, top and bottom, hold the panels together. The float surface is the walking surface. There is no lumber, no decking, no timber frame underneath.
Freight is quoted separately, with 5 to 10 business days processing. Anchoring is not included. Tommy Docks sells anchoring separately and states that explicitly on the product page.
The appeal is real and worth saying plainly. Two people, no saw, no drill, one afternoon. If you need a swim platform off a lake cottage, a spot for a PWC port, or a small seasonal dock you pull out every autumn, the package does exactly what it promises. Renters, cottagers, anyone who wants to spend a weekend on the water rather than building a dock, this format makes sense for them.
The constraints show up when you want more than about 64 square feet or a shape other than a straight rectangle. Because modules are 4 ft x 8 ft, your dock is always a multiple of that unit. An L-shape, a wider section at the end for a boat to tie alongside, a finger ramp off a seawall, none of those happen with panels. And the price is the same per module whether you buy two or twenty. At $39.84 per square foot, a larger dock gets expensive fast.
Modular platforms also sit low and stable in calm water, which some people prefer for swimming and for boarding a PWC. That is a genuine characteristic, not a flaw.
What You Get in a DIY Dock Framing Kit
The floating dock kits at Dock Builders Supply are engineered hardware packages designed to work together as a system. Each kit includes dock floats, lags and washers to attach the floats, framing hardware and framing fasteners. The floating dock framing hardware covers the brackets and connectors that tie the frame together, sized and matched so you are not hunting for a compatible part at a local hardware store on a Saturday.
What the kit does not include: frame lumber and decking, which you buy locally since freight on lumber is prohibitive, and connection hardware like hoops or pipe holders, because what you need depends on whether the dock ties to posts, pilings or a seawall. You can research and find the connection side at our floating dock mooring products page.
That list of exclusions is not a drawback dressed up as a feature. It reflects how dock construction actually works. Lumber prices move and vary by region. Shipping dimensional lumber across the country adds cost without adding value. You pick it up at your local yard, cut it on site, and the hardware arrives ready to bolt together.
The same logic applies to connection hardware like hoops or pipe holders. A dock on a lake bottom anchor needs different hardware than one sliding on pilings, and the right choice depends on your site. The free plans and the flotation calculator help you figure out what your site needs before you order anything.
The structural result is a framed dock: a timber or composite frame with floats underneath and decking on top. That construction lets you place floats where the load sits, choose the hardware grade for your water, and repair one component without touching the rest of the dock. It is a different object than a modular float platform, and the difference matters once the dock needs to do more than float.

The Real Cost, Worked Out
The clearest way to compare the two routes is to price the same finished dock. Eight feet by sixteen feet, 128 square feet, is a common size and there is a kit for it, so that is the number to use.
The Tommy Docks route to 128 square feet takes four packages, since each covers 32 square feet. Four packages at $1,275.00 each is $5,100.00. Anchoring is not included and is sold separately. Freight is quoted separately. The buyer supplies nothing further. That works out to $39.84 per square foot, before anchoring.
The Dock Builders Supply route is the 8x16 Floating Dock Kit at $1,427.46. The kit includes the floats, framing hardware, lags and fasteners. Frame lumber and decking are extra, bought locally. Connection hardware like hoops or pipe holders is also extra, as it is on the Tommy Docks route for anchoring. The hardware and flotation cost alone works out to $11.15 per square foot.
Lumber and decking are genuinely extra. Saying that plainly is what makes the $11.15 figure mean something. Anyone serious enough to build a dock knows they are buying lumber. The figure covers what arrives in the kit, nothing more and nothing less.
This table shows both routes to the same 128 square feet side by side.
| Item | Tommy Docks (4 packages) | DockBuilders.com 8x16 Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | 128 sq ft (4 x 32 sq ft) | 128 sq ft |
| Package or kit price | $5,100.00 | $1,427.46 |
| Per square foot | $39.84 | $11.15 |
| Floats included | Yes | Yes |
| Securing hardware | Not included | Not included |
| Buyer also supplies | Nothing further | Frame lumber and decking |
| Freight | Quoted separately | Quoted at checkout (or quoted for custom kits) |
The gap widens as the dock gets bigger. The modular price is fixed at $39.84 per square foot regardless of how many panels you buy. A framed dock does not scale that way. The 10x20 kit covers 200 square feet for $2,059.46, which is $10.30 per square foot in hardware and flotation. Bigger gets cheaper per foot on the framed route. It stays the same on the packaged route.
This table shows the DockBuilders.com kit range with the per-square-foot hardware cost for each size.
| Kit | Price | Size | Square Feet | Per Sq Ft (hardware + floats) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8' x 16' Floating Dock Kit | $1,427.46 | 8 x 16 | 128 | $11.15 |
| 8' x 16' Low Profile | $1,623.58 | 8 x 16 | 128 | $12.68 |
| 12' x 12' Floating Dock Kit | $1,519.32 | 12 x 12 | 144 | $10.55 |
| 10' x 20' Floating Dock Kit | $2,059.46 | 10 x 20 | 200 | $10.30 |
Size and Shape: Where Packages Stop Working
A modular dock is built in fixed increments. The Tommy Docks FLEXX panel is 4 ft x 8 ft, so your finished dock is always a combination of that rectangle. You can arrange panels in a line or a grid, but you cannot make an L-shape, a T-shape or a wider head section without ending up with an awkward gap or a configuration that does not connect cleanly.
That matters if your shoreline is not straight, if you want a boat to tie alongside on one side and a PWC ramp on the other, or if the bottom of your lake slopes in a direction that makes a standard rectangle impractical. It also matters for a dock that serves a boat slip, where the finger dimensions need to match the boat rather than the nearest panel multiple.
A framed dock is whatever shape you draw. L-shapes, T-shapes, a finger off a seawall, a wider section at the end for a table and chairs. The frame lumber is cut to dimension on site. The hardware accommodates the layout rather than dictating it.
The free floating dock plans at DockBuilders.com cover several common sizes and shapes and give you a materials list to work from. If your site is straightforward, the plans do most of the design work before you buy anything. If it is not, they are a starting point for the conversation about what hardware you actually need.
Flotation, Loading and How It Rides
A modular platform floats on the floats built into the panels. You do not choose their placement or size. For a small swim platform or a light-duty dock, that is fine. The panels are rated and you stay inside the rating.
A framed dock lets you place floats where the load is. If a boat ties to one end, you put more flotation there. If one corner carries a cleat and a tackle box and not much else, you size accordingly. Use the flotation calculator to work out how many floats your build needs rather than guessing. A DPI 36x48x12 float carries 677 lb of buoyancy. A DPI 24x48x12 carries 442 lb. Placing them to match the actual load keeps the deck level and the dock riding correctly in the water.
Modular platforms do sit low and stable in calm water. For a lake with little fetch, that is a real advantage for boarding a PWC or getting out of the water after a swim. A framed dock with a timber frame sits a little higher and can handle chop better, which matters on exposed water or anywhere a boat wash reaches the dock regularly.

When Something Breaks
This is where the structural difference between a modular platform and a framed dock shows up most clearly, and it tends to be the argument that lands hardest with anyone who has owned a dock for more than a few years.
A cracked or waterlogged FLEXX float is a proprietary part. It comes from one supplier. If that supplier raises the price, changes the design or discontinues the line, you are either patching a damaged panel or replacing the whole module. There is no aftermarket for a proprietary polyethylene float shape.
A damaged float under a framed dock is a different problem. You unbolt it, slide it out from under the frame, and bolt a replacement in. The frame above it does not move. The decking above does not move. You replace one part and the dock is back to spec.
The same logic applies to the framing hardware. Standard brackets and connectors are sold in matched sets and kept in stock. If a bracket corrodes in salt water after ten years, you replace the bracket. You do not replace a panel or call a dealer to find out whether that part still exists.
Maintenance on a framed dock is incremental. You are replacing a float, a fastener, a section of decking. Maintenance on a modular system means working within that system's parts availability, which is a dependency you are taking on for the life of the dock.
Skill, Time and Tools
A framed dock build needs a circular saw, a drill and a level at minimum. Two people for a weekend, possibly two weekends for an 8x16 depending on the site and how much of the work happens on land versus in the water. That is a real time cost and the article would not be honest if it glossed over it.
A modular package assembles in an afternoon. Two people, no cutting, no measuring lumber, panels click and bolt together on a flat surface or in shallow water. If that weekend is the last warm one of the season and you want a dock in the water this afternoon, the package wins that argument outright.
The question is whether that convenience is worth $3,672.54 on a 128-square-foot dock. For some buyers it is. For a renter who needs to pull the dock out every October, or for a property with no tool storage and no one comfortable with a saw, the package is the right answer and there is no shame in saying so.
- Review your site: measure the area, note the bottom type, water depth and any existing structure like pilings or a seawall.
- Choose your route: modular package if the dock is small, temporary or no tools are available; framing kit if the dock is larger than 128 square feet, needs a custom shape or is a permanent install.
- Run the flotation calculator at DockBuilders.com to confirm how many floats your build requires before ordering.
- Download the free floating dock plans that match your size and shape to get a materials list for lumber and decking.
- Order the kit; buy frame lumber and decking locally to avoid freight costs on dimensional lumber.
- Determine and order connection hardware separately: pile hoops, pipe holders or anchoring hardware matched to your site.
- Build on land where possible, then move the assembled sections to the water.
Which Should You Choose
The package route suits a small platform, a seasonal dock you remove each autumn, a property where nobody wants to pick up a saw, a renter, or anyone who values their free weekend more than the price difference. For a swim platform off a lake cottage or a single-PWC port, four modules and an afternoon is a perfectly reasonable answer.
The DIY framing kit suits anything over about 128 square feet, any shape that is not a straight rectangle, permanent installs, salt water where you want to choose your own hardware grade, and anyone who plans to own the dock for ten or more years and wants to replace one part rather than a whole module. It also suits anyone who has looked at $5,100 for 128 square feet and decided the lumber bill and two weekends is a better trade. Not to mention you have far more universal options for dock accessories that'll attach to your dock like cleats, dock ladders,
The honest version of the comparison is that modular packages are priced for convenience and suited to small and temporary applications. Once the dock gets past a certain size or needs to serve a boat reliably through seasons of use, the framed construction approach costs less, lasts longer and stays repairable.
Frequently asked questions
What are the alternatives to Tommy Docks?
The main alternative is to build a framed dock yourself using a framing kit, dock floats and lumber sourced locally. DockBuilders.com sells floating dock kits starting at $1,427.46 for an 8x16, with free plans and a flotation calculator included. The kits include the floats and all framing hardware. You supply frame lumber, decking and connection hardware like hoops or pipe holders.
Is it cheaper to build your own floating dock?
Yes. An 8x16 framed dock kit runs $1,427.46 in hardware and flotation, about $11.15 per square foot, against $5,100 for four Tommy Docks packages covering the same area at $39.84 per square foot. Lumber and decking are extra on the DIY side. Anchoring is extra on both sides. The gap in hardware cost alone is substantial, and it widens as the dock gets bigger.
How much does a floating dock cost to build?
The 8x16 kit at DockBuilders.com is $1,427.46, which covers the floats and all framing hardware at $11.15 per square foot. Add frame lumber, decking and connection hardware like hoops or pipe holders. A 10x20 kit is $2,059.46, which works out to $10.30 per square foot in hardware and flotation. Lumber costs vary by region and are not included in those figures.
How many floats does a floating dock need?
It depends on the deck weight and what you put on it. A DPI 36x48x12 float carries 677 lb of buoyancy. A DPI 24x48x12 carries 442 lb. Rather than estimating, run the flotation calculator at DockBuilders.com, which sizes the float count for your specific build dimensions and expected load.
Can you build a floating dock without a kit?
You can, but the kit exists because sourcing compatible framing brackets, connectors and fasteners individually takes time and you can end up three parts short on a Saturday with the lumber already cut. The kit bundles hardware that is already sized and engineered to work together, which is most of its value. The floats are included too, so you are not sourcing them separately.
Do modular dock packages include anchoring?
Usually not. Tommy Docks states anchoring is not included with their floating packages and sells it separately. The DockBuilders.com kits do not include connection hardware like hoops or pipe holders either, since the right choice depends on whether the dock ties to posts, pilings or a seawall. Budget for securing hardware on either route.
How long does it take to build a floating dock?
A framed 8x16 dock with two people, a circular saw and a drill takes a weekend, sometimes two depending on the site. A modular package from Tommy Docks assembles in an afternoon with no tools. That time difference is real, and for some buyers it is worth the price gap. For a permanent dock on a property you own, the build time is a one-time cost.